Before and After: Our Lady of Mount Carmel Church in Newport News, Virginia

Today we are featuring a church renovation project that features the parish church of Our Lady of Mount Carmel, located in Newport News, Virginia. Now if that name is familiar, it may be because it was one the church buildings discussed in Michael Rose's 2001 book, Ugly as Sin (which includes the telling subtitle, "Why They Changed Our Churches from Sacred Places to Meeting Spaces and How We Can Change Them Back Again") -- at least so I am told, I have never actually owned a copy of Rose's book.

The original design followed a plan that was fashionable in the later decades of the twentieth century.  It was effectively a kind of church in the round with elevated, sloping, theatre style seating surrounding the altar. There really was no clearly defined sanctuary and the altar and ambo were not fixed.  The whole notion of this type of arrangement was based upon the particular pet ideas of liturgists of later twentieth century who typically were fixated on horizontal notions of the liturgy and liturgical architecture. 

Here we can see the church in its "before" incarnation:

BEFORE:

So, what to do with a space like this? How can it be brought into alignment with a classical Catholic liturgical ordering? First off, the sloping seating was removed and the floor levelled and a clearly defined (and raised) sanctuary space was created, inclusive of an altar rail surrounding the sanctuary.  Wood-carved statuary set into niches were also added, as well as a grandiose crucifix and stained glass window. A new, fixed, stone altar of sacrifice and altar of reservation (with a reredos) were also installed.  A Romanesque style ceiling was added, as were arches and columns. Painted stencilling was added to the ceiling. In short, the church was effectively redone entirely. 

These various works were undertaken by Nic Charbonneau and John Parker Wilmeth of Harrison Design with the stonework for the new baptismal font, altar of sacrifice and altar of reservation by Rugo Stone. The decorative painting was completed by Conrad Schmitt Studios and the carved statuary by ALBL Oberammergau. Finally, the altar rail and pews were completed by New Holland Church Furniture

Let's take a look at what they managed to accomplish.

AFTER:




Altar of sacrifice

Altar of reservation





A truly impressive transformation. Let's hope the church now gets attention for its art and architecture for rather different reasons than it did previously. 

-------
Do you like Liturgical Arts Journal's original content? You can help support LAJ in its mission and vision to promote beauty in Catholic worship either by: 


You choose the amount! Your support makes all the difference.

Join in the conversation on our Facebook page.

Share: